TL;DR: To interview a pet sitter, ask about their experience, how they’d handle emergencies, and their routine for your dog or cat. Questions like “What’s your plan if my pet gets sick?” or “How do you calm a nervous pup?” reveal their skills. Check references, weigh their answers, and write a recommendation if they shine. It’s your pet’s VIP ticket to the right care.
Why interviewing a pet sitter is a big deal
Hiring a pet sitter isn’t like picking a pizza delivery guy—your furry family member’s well-being is on the line. A quick chat can uncover if they’re a pro who gets your pet’s quirks or a dud who’ll forget the food bowl. Asking the right questions ensures you’re not rolling the dice on your dog’s zoomies or your cat’s nap schedule.
Your pet’s safety hangs in the balance
A sitter who can’t spot a limp or doesn’t know pet CPR could turn a weekend away into a vet nightmare. Interviews aren’t just formalities—they’re your shield against chaos. You’re not overthinking it; you’re protecting your pet’s throne.
Beyond the basics—why questions matter
Availability’s nice, but can they handle your dog’s leash-pulling tantrums or your cat’s 3 a.m. meow opera? The Care.com guide stops at surface stuff—we’re diving deeper. Questions peel back the layers, showing if they’re a match or a mismatch for your pet’s needs.
Set the stage for the interview
Before you fire off questions, get your ducks—or paws—in a row.
Prep like a pro before you start
Know your pet’s deal—daily walks, pill times, that weird couch-chewing habit. Jot down must-haves: in-home care or drop-ins? Special skills like calming anxious pets? A solid prep list keeps you focused—check out this prep checklist for a head start.
Where to find candidates worth grilling
Ask your vet, hit up local pet groups, or browse online platforms with vetted pros. Word-of-mouth beats random flyers every time—your neighbor’s glowing review might lead you to gold. Set up a call or meet-and-greet once you’ve got a shortlist 🐶.
Ask the must-know questions
Start with the essentials—these are your dealmakers or breakers.
What questions should I ask a potential pet sitter?
Kick off with the biggies: “How long have you been sitting pets?” “What breeds have you worked with?” “How do you handle emergencies—say, my dog eats something weird?” These reveal experience, comfort with your pet’s type, and crisis smarts. Don’t skip “What’s your backup plan if you can’t make it?”—reliability’s non-negotiable.
Questions to ask when interviewing potential pet sitters
Drill into specifics: “How would you manage my cat’s finicky eating?” “What’s your routine for a high-energy dog?” “Ever dealt with separation anxiety?” These pinpoint how they’ll handle your pet’s unique vibe—generic answers won’t cut it. Add “Can you send daily updates?”—proof they’re on it keeps you sane.
Your Pets Deserve More Than a Like. They Deserve a Community.
Your Pets Deserve More Than a Like. They Deserve a Community.
Dig deeper with follow-ups
Surface answers only get you so far—probe to see the real deal. Need more ideas for questions to ask? Here are 10 more questions to ask a pet sitter during an interview.
What questions are asked in a pet interview?
Follow up with “Tell me about a time a pet got sick—how’d you handle it?” or “What did you do when a dog wouldn’t stop barking?” Real stories beat hypotheticals. Ask “How do you spot if my pet’s off?”—it tests their observation skills, not just their talk.
Probe their pet-handling chops
Push harder: “What’s your trick for a cat who hides?” “How do you tire out a pup who’s all go?” “Ever had a pet escape—what happened?” These show if they’ve got the instincts and experience to match your pet’s personality—vague “I’d figure it out” responses are a pass.
Wrap it up with trust checks
You’ve got the answers—now lock in the trust factor.
References and red flags
Ask for references—past clients who can vouch for “They caught my dog’s limp early” or “My cat loved them.” No refs? Big nope. Watch for dodgy vibes—evasive answers, no pet tales, or “I’ve never had an issue” (too perfect smells fishy). Trust your gut here.
How do you write a recommendation for a pet sitter?
If they ace it, leave a review later: “They walked my Lab twice a day and nailed her meds—I’d rebook in a heartbeat.” Keep it specific—what they did, how it helped. Short, honest praise like “Daily pics kept me calm” helps others pick them too—check this guide for more.
Join the elite club of pet owners who know it all. Subscribe to the Petme newsletter now.
Make your decision
Time to pick your pet’s new sidekick—here’s how to seal it.
Weighing the answers
Rank them on experience (years, breeds), problem-solving (emergency tales), and fit (your pet’s needs). A sitter who says “I’d call the vet if your cat skips meals” beats “I’d wait it out.” Confidence, not cockiness, wins—cross-check with references for the full picture.
Next steps after the interview
Book a trial run—say, a day or two—to test the vibe. Lay out your pet’s routine in writing, share vet info, and agree on updates. If it works, you’ve got your pro. Want to flip the script and become a sitter? Apply on Petme to join the ranks.
Conclusion: Nail the pet sitter interview
Interviewing a pet sitter is all about asking the right questions—from “What’s your experience?” to “How do you handle chaos?”—and digging into their answers. Check refs, test the fit, and write a killer recommendation if they shine 🌟. Your pet deserves a pro who gets them—master this, and you’ll both rest easy.
FAQs: Pet sitter interview essentials
1. How many questions should I ask a pet sitter?
Aim for 8-10 solid ones—enough to cover experience, emergencies, and your pet’s quirks without dragging on. Start with “How long have you been sitting?” and build to “What’s your plan if my dog bolts?” Quality beats quantity—focus on what reveals their skills.
2. What if a sitter’s answers feel off?
Trust your instincts—if they dodge questions like “Ever had a pet emergency?” or give vague “I’d handle it” replies, they’re not the one. Hesitation or no specifics can signal inexperience. Ask a follow-up—“Can you give an example?”—and see if they squirm.
3. Should I interview more than one sitter?
Yes, if you can—two or three gives you options. Compare how they tackle “How would you calm my anxious cat?” or “What’s your routine for walks?” It’s not overkill; it’s finding the best fit for your pet’s VIP status.
4. How do I spot a sitter who’s great with my pet’s needs?
Look for tailored answers—“I’d play fetch to tire out your hyper pup” or “I’ve fed picky cats before.” Generic responses like “I love all pets” don’t cut it. Real pros match their skills to your pet’s profile, no guesswork.
5. Can I ask about their pet sitting side hustle?
Sure—try “How do you balance multiple gigs?” It shows if they’re stretched thin. A pro might say, “I limit bookings to stay on top.” Want in on the action? Apply to become a pet sitter on Petme and turn your pet love into cash.
Pet sitter interviews are key. Ask smart, pick right—your pet’s next pro is waiting! 🐶
